Feedback Week...

[kennahijja]

Well, I managed my week of writing proper feedback for every story read, and feel it's an experiment worth repeating, though not necessarily when I'm this busy :). OK, two exceptions to confess to up front: I started on a long non-HP piece that doesn't count. And there's one HP fic that's – objectively – well-written, daring, amazingly characterised/plotted, but included a ton of my squicks. I don't shy away from concrit, but as it's my problem not the story's that I disliked it, there's no need to give a meh-response to an amazing author (no, none of you). There *is* a time for silence.

If you're interested – below is the list of fic, some read for fun, some by chance, some for fandom duties (asterisks to mark my top favourites):

A Helping Hand by mad_maudlin [Slughorn; Percy, gen, PG]
A Penny Earned by the_con_cept [Ron/Lucius, NC-17] **
Almost by pre_raphaelite1 [Lucius/Narcissa, gen/het, PG]
Camouflage by liriaen [Draco/Ron, G]
Duty and Duality by dracos_doll [Harry/Lucius, NC-17]
Flowers and Herbs by minerva_fan [Minerva, gen, G]
From Another Perspective by kabeyk [Harry/Draco, NC-17]
Harsh Reality by cock_a_snook [Harry; Snape, gen, PG]
I want. What I want. by corvidae9 [Snape/Draco, Draco/Harry, R] **
Kriegspiel by mad_maudlin [Ron; Lucius, gen, R] **
Most Loved by kabeyk [Regulus/Sirius, Lucius/Sirius, NC-17] **
Nevermore by thescarletwoman [Remus/Harry, NC-17]
No Big Loss by the_con_cept [Harry/Snape, R]
Pas de Deux by lysa1 [Snape/Lucius/surprise, NC-17]
Race by ravenna_c_tan [Harry/Draco, Lucius/Draco, NC-17]**
Some Enchanted Evening by coyotegoth [Lucius; Severus, gen, PG-ish]
Switch by corvidae9 [Twins; various, gen, G] **
The Rules of Malfoy by sirryluv [Draco/Lucius, NC-17]
Weeks by ravenna_c_tan [Draco/Lucius, Harry/Draco, NC-17]**
Welcome to my Life by k155_me [Harry/Lucius, Vernon/Dudley, NC-17]

And yes, I usually read a lot more, but as I said... busy.

Comments

[ariadneelda.livejournal.com]

Ooh, and I was just looking for something good to read. :-)

[kennahijja.livejournal.com]

*grin*
Only one that wasn't at least ok, and a lot I found very good, so I hope you'll find something :).

[ariadneelda.livejournal.com]

Oh, I did! Just read the Blackcest one by kabeyk, and wow, it was amazing. So thank you! I would have missed such a great story if not for your post. :-)

[magic-helmet.livejournal.com]

Oooh, thanks for that! Some great links there!

[kennahijja.livejournal.com]

Yes, I was lucky and had great fun that week :).

[coyotegoth.livejournal.com]

No idea why I said "least"- I meant to say "rec". Senility...